Growing up, I remember my mother — who did all the finances for the family — preparing the annual tax return. She’d have forms and receipts and journal books spread out on the table, since we had a farm and had to report income from the farm. She was meticulous, and would check and double check her figures. “Twice we were audited,” she once proudly told me, “and they found nothing.”
Well, Mom’s way of doing taxes, with pencil and scrap paper, has fallen by the wayside. An IRS study shows that increasingly, people are turning to paid tax preparers to do their taxes. They’re also using more software packages to prepare their taxes themselves. In fact, for the 2007 and 2008 tax years, 80% of taxpayers filed their taxes using either software or a paid preparer.
What many people don’t know is that tax preparation is a field that has no prerequisites. That’s right. Anyone can be a tax preparer. It’s easier to become a tax preparer than a hair stylist. All you need to do is hang out a shingle or print up a business card. Of course, many people who are in the business of preparing taxes do have education and certification in the field: attorneys, certified public accountants (of which I am one) and enrolled agents. These people are subject to professional oversight, and have to register and establish competency in their field, and submit to continuing education every year in order to remain certified. But there’s this vast number of tax preparers who don’t fall into any of those categories, including most of the preparers at the big-box tax companies (H&R Block, and Jackson-Hewitt, for example) and whose work is completely unregulated. The IRS doesn’t really know how many tax preparers there are, but suspects the number is somewhere between 900,000 and 1.2 million.
The IRS is about to shake things up, though, in the tax world. (I know, I know, that’s kind of an odd image, isn’t it?) Starting in 2011, the IRS would require all tax preparers in every state who are not attorneys, CPAs or Enrolled Agents to pass a basic competency exam, register, and take annual continuing education in tax law and ethics. It’s already changed this year for preparers in New York State. The previously-unregulated preparers will have to register with the state, pay a fee, and get an ID number to allow the state to track, and possibly deny registration to preparers who consistently file erroneous returns. However, the changes that the IRS are proposing are more comprehensive, and to my mind, make much more sense. Why not have the people charged with preparing taxes at least submit to exhibiting a basic competency in the field before you allow them to prepare taxes?
Taxes are complicated, and getting more so all the time. Every year there are changes, and new tax rulings. This change will create a more level playing field in the area of tax preparation. After all, if you have someone who has an advanced degree, 16 hours of rigorous testing, 24 hours per year of continuing education, an expensive triennial registration fee, and a professional tax preparation software costing upwards of $600 competing against someone who simply bought a software program — maybe even a single return copy of TurboTax for $29.95 and files an unlimited number of returns, guess who’s going to be able to prepare your return more cheaply?
I applaud the IRS for this step, as did 98% of the people who provided public comment on this new regulation. And with the IRS and the tax-strapped State performing more audits, it really pays to have your return prepared professionally. Maybe not for the college student who basically has a handful of interest and a W-2 from a summer job, but for the person with perhaps a home purchase or sale, or a small side business, or rental properties, it makes sense to engage a professional. As the saying goes, “you get what you pay for!’ How true!